CLIENT BRIEFING & ARTICLE
SANJIV NADDAN & HUAN INSIGHTS
Publication Series 3/2026
PRACTICE AREAS: Dispute Resolution | Trusts, Shareholder Disputes & Insolvency
Family businesses often park shares in a relative’s name, sometimes for succession, sometimes to keep assets beyond the reach of creditors. The second motive carries a price. In the Court of Appeal decision Low Yee Meng v Lau Kok Loon @ Lau Say Siok [2026] CLJU 3951, an uncle who transferred his share to his nephew on the eve of bankruptcy, and waited 25 years to ask for it back, was left with nothing.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY & KEY TAKEAWAYS
Resulting Trust is a Presumption, Not a Rule: Want of consideration is important but not decisive. The court must weigh all the circumstances of the transfer, including an executed trust deed, the transferor’s long silence and the timing of any later claim.
Pleadings Read Holistically: A bare averment that a paragraph “is admitted” will not be treated as an admission where the rest of the pleading plainly contradicts it.
Illegality Bars Relief: Applying Detik Ria v Prudential, where an asset is transferred to defeat bankruptcy law, the illegality strikes at the heart of the bargain. Relief is refused even if the particular creditor suffered no loss, because the bankruptcy process and the Director General of Insolvency were kept in the dark.
1. Background Facts
The respondent and his brother were the original shareholders of Semenyih Jaya Sdn Bhd (“Company”), holding one share each. The Company’s principal asset was land in Semenyih which, the High Court found, the respondent alone had paid for.
In 1989 the brothers were sued by a bank as guarantors. On 16 May 1990, the respondent executed a trust deed (“Trust Deed”) declaring that he held his one share on trust for his nephew, the appellant, “on account of natural love and affection”. The respondent’s brother did the same for the respondent’s son. On 15 July 1995, the respondent transferred his share to the appellant. He was adjudged bankrupt on 2 August 1995. Through later allotments and a bonus issue, that single share grew to 238,096 shares, about 48% of the Company.
2. Decision of the High Court
Resulting Trust Found: The High Court held that, as the share was transferred without consideration and the presumption of advancement does not apply between uncle and nephew, a resulting trust arose over the original share and all shares accruing from it.
Trust Deed a Sham: The trial judge treated the appellant’s plea that “Paragraph 10 is admitted” as an admission that the Trust Deed was a sham.
Illegality No Bar: Applying the “trio of considerations” in Patel v Mirza [2017] AC 487, the court found the bank had not been prejudiced (it accepted about RM9.1 million against a debt of RM14.8 million, secured by a property worth considerably more), so denying relief would hand the appellant a windfall.
3. Decision of the Court of Appeal: No Resulting Trust
The Court of Appeal (Quorum: Ravinthran Paramaguru FCJ, Faizah Jamaludin JCA and Ahmad Shahrir Mohd Salleh JCA) allowed the appeal. Applying Westdeutsche Landesbank v Islington LBC and Takako Sakao v Ng Pek Yuen, the Court stressed that a resulting trust rests on the transferor’s presumed intention at the time of transfer. Absence of consideration is important but not determinative; otherwise a donor could reclaim a genuine gift upon a belated change of heart.
The Court found that the trial judge had not given sufficient weight to the unqualified Trust Deed, which satisfied the three certainties and was completely constituted on transfer in 1995. As a trust instrument rather than a contract, section 26 of the Contracts Act 1950 did not apply and no consideration was required. The 25-year delay, and the fact that the claim surfaced only after the appellant accused the respondent of siphoning Company funds, pointed to a retaliatory claim and “post-transfer regret”. Who paid for the land in 1983 was background, not proof of the intention behind a share transfer 12 years later.
On the alleged admission, the Court held that pleadings must be read holistically. The same and succeeding paragraphs of the defence affirmed the validity of the Trust Deed, so the opening words “Paragraph 10 is admitted” could not be read as conceding a sham.
4. Illegality Bars Relief
The Court went further. Even if a resulting trust had arisen, relief would be refused. On the respondent’s own case, the share was transferred to put it beyond his creditors, engaging section 109 of the Insolvency Act 1967 and section 422 of the Penal Code.
Following the Federal Court in Detik Ria Sdn Bhd v Prudential Corporation Holdings Ltd [2025] 4 CLJ 159, which cautioned against importing Patel v Mirza wholesale given sections 24 and 66 of the Contracts Act 1950, the Court considered the centrality of the illegality and the proportionality of refusing relief. Evading bankruptcy law was not incidental; it was the sole purpose of the arrangement.
The Court rejected the “no harm done” argument. Bankruptcy concerns not one creditor but potential creditors and the Director General of Insolvency, who takes custody of the bankrupt’s property by law. Both were kept in the dark. Knight v Knight [2019] EWHC 915 (Ch) was distinguished: there the Official Receiver had investigated the transfer and taken no action, and all proving creditors were paid in full.
The appeal was thus allowed with costs of RM120,000 here and below.
5. Essential Lessons for Shareholders and Families
Asset Shielding Is a One-Way Street: Transferring shares or property to relatives to keep them from creditors cannot safely be undone through the courts. If the transferee refuses to return them, relief is unlikely, even where the creditor was ultimately paid.
Document True Intentions at the Outset: A trust deed means what it says. A settlor who later alleges a sham faces an uphill task. Nominee arrangements should be recorded expressly and accurately when made.
Do Not Sit on Your Rights: Long inaction is evidence. Decades of silence may be read as consistent with an outright gift rather than a retained beneficial interest.
Plead Admissions with Precision: Courts read pleadings as a whole, but an unqualified “admitted” invites dispute. Admit only what is intended and qualify expressly.
SANJIV NADDAN
Partner
Email: sanjiv@sanjivhuan.com
Mobile: 016 – 277 2433
DISCLAIMER & NOTICE: The material in this publication is intended to provide general information and guidance only and does not constitute formal legal or professional advice. Readers should seek specific legal counsel regarding any individual matter or transaction before taking action.
© 2026 Sanjiv Naddan & Huan Advocates and Solicitors. All rights reserved.